Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: [Spoiler Warning] My Puzzle Box Thoughts

  1. #1

    Lightbulb [Spoiler Warning] My Puzzle Box Thoughts

    I have been watching this form for quite a while now but have chosen not to get involved. I solved the Lunchbox and Puzzle Box independantly using some quick programs I wrote; I'm considering posting them here. At any rate I opened the Puzzle Box on the somethinginthesea website and here is what Orrin says once it opens and my breakdown of it? Just asking for opinions and seeing what everybody else here thinks:

    Complete text:

    1 Oh magus, you have begun thy journey.
    2 Your master's temple has fallen but his work is not yet finished.
    3 Turn south by west toward great Muhheakantuck. Upon it's shoulder shall you find the decrepit corpse of the red queen.
    4 If you would run her race then seek her crown jewels, they wait beyond the looking glass.
    5 Follow the twinkling of gems oh seeker, and you shall unlock the roads to rapture.
    6 This is Orrin Oscar Lutwidge, September 1958.


    Line-by-line Breakdown:

    1 Oh magus, you have begun thy journey.

    This line seems innocent enough. It seems to just say welcome to the journey. I presume that the journey is to reach Rapture; though it could be otherwise.
    Though what is a magus?
    Wikipedia says:
    "to denote a follower of Zoroaster, or rather, a follower of what the Hellenistic world associated Zoroaster with, which was – in the main – the ability to read the stars, and manipulate the fate that the stars foretold. The meaning prior to Hellenistic period is uncertain."

    This seems to suggest maybe, us, the ones on this journey are driven by fate?? Does not make much sense.

    "This association was in turn the product of the Hellenistic fascination for (Pseudo-)Zoroaster, who was perceived by the Greeks to be the "Chaldean" "founder" of the Magi and "inventor" of both astrology and magic."

    This makes more sense. There is magic in rapture; rather splicers and their plasmids but does this make sense?
    Could Orrin Oscar Lutwidge know anything about Plasmids yet? Had they even been invented yet?

    <http://forums.2kgames.com/forums/showthread.php?t=13400>
    "Rapture as a city was completed in 1946."
    "The game takes place in 1960"
    Dianne Mclintock is first attacked "New Year's Ever 1958... That's why it says, "Happy 1959!"."
    Orrin is leaving this message as of 1958 (see 6)

    The war took a few years to escalate to violence on the streets. But plasmids were invented in the beginning of the war; they are what started the arms race bettween Fontaine and Ryan. Therefore it is conceivable that Orrin could have found out about them and even more likely that he would have percieved it as magic which is why he refers to us a a magus. Someone who is seeking magic.

    That is all I can think of for this line and I may have covered the purpose of the date in line 6 in the same stroke.

    2 Your master's temple has fallen but his work is not yet finished.

    Don't know what this means? Does he mean the fall of Rapture? Could he know about that? When in 1958 did he leave this message? Wait, just checked, September. It seems that that was the point of the last line. To give this date for reference. So this was a few months before McClintock was attacked. The war was going full swing by then. It is quite possible that Orrin could know that Rapture was falling into disarray.

    "masters temple" = "Rapture" ??

    Rapture "has fallen"? Well that's true, but how does he know that (information source?) and what is he trying to achieve?

    "work is not yet finished"? Hinting that Rapture needs to be rebuilt?

    (Hmmmm, i read from IGN that the Big Sister is not the main adversary in the new game. With talk like "Rapture's work is not yet finished" that sounds ominous and like Lutwidge is lining up to be the next villian: pure speculation this though)

    3 Turn south by west toward great Muhheakantuck. Upon it's shoulder shall you find the decrepit corpse of the red queen.

    "Red Queen" was the answer my program came up with as the solution to the Puzzle Box; it was correct.

    Muhheakantuck refers to a river that "flows both ways". I believe that this must refer to the American Hudson river because that is the only one in America that matches that description. There also seemed to be one in the middle east I think but that makes no sense to this story line. Also the hudson river is near new york and goes out to sea near the bermuda triangle. Into the same ocean that leads to Rapture. If you wanted to place a submersible in an ideal location to get people to Rapture then the mouth of the Hudson river would be an ideal location.

    The "shoulder" may refer to the mouth of the river because this is where the arm (river) meets the body (ocean). This means that at the mouth of the Hudson river lies the "decrepit corpse of the red queen"

    decrepit => "Weakened or worn out from age or wear" (Wikipedia)
    corpse => (dictionary.com)
    1. a dead body, usually of a human being.
    2. something no longer useful or viable: rusting corpses of old cars.
    3. Obsolete. a human or animal body, whether alive or dead.
    I think meaning 2 being no longer useful of viable in interesting.

    Red Queen => Big Sister not around then so It cannot be her.
    => Submarine to rapture???

    Spectulation: This seems to suggest that at the mouth of the hudson river lies a submersible (possible with a red glow or called the red queen) that was once used to get people to rapture in the early days but has been forgotten about and is lying there waiting to be used and is growing old and decrepit; like a corpse.

    4 If you would run her race then seek her crown jewels, they wait beyond the looking glass.

    Interesting, "running the red queens race" and "the looking glass" an obvious Alice in Wonderland reference but please note that it is not in reference to the first and more pupular book but rather the second. The one that most people don't have experience in. (Worth reading??) Also is the reference too obvious; is it trying to distract?

    The red queens race is best illustrated by these two lines:

    "Well, in our country," said Alice, still panting a little, "you'd generally get to somewhere else — if you run very fast for a long time, as we've been doing."
    "A slow sort of country!" said the Queen. "Now, here, you see, it takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place. If you want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as that!"

    Essentially the red queens race is one in which you cannot go anywhere and you can never ever move fast enough to get anywhere. So does this suggest that seeking "her crown jewels" is a pointless endeavor that will not go anywhere? And they wait beyond the looking glass. A looking glass is another name for a mirror. Does this mean that whatever her crown jewels are they can be seen but never touched. As in, on the other side of the mirror???

    Maybe go back to this.

    5 Follow the twinkling of gems oh seeker, and you shall unlock the roads to rapture.

    Follow the twinkling of gems (not jewels; what's the difference?) and you shall unlock the road to rapture. That seems straight forward enough. Are the twinkling gems lights or some sort (on the ocean floor)? Follow the lights to reach the submersible that can take you to Rapture?? I'm not sure, really don't know enough here.

    6 This is Orrin Oscar Lutwidge, September 1958.

    We already know his name so that was of no use but the date helped in the timeline above. Very useful info in the date given.

    Overall:

    I think this message says that is you goto the Hudson river in America and look for glowing lights on the ocean floor around the mouth of the river then they will lead you to a submersible that can take you to Rapture.

    Conclusion

    Anyway, these are just my thoughts. Let me know what you think.

  2. #2
    your good

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Apr 2009
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    1,806
    Those are some really good theories... I thought "The Looking Glass" could have been the ocean since you can see yourself reflected in it just like a mirror... How long did it take you to write all of that?

  4. #4
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Hidden
    Posts
    2,518
    Here's what I came up with after reading your explanation:

    1: "Seeker, you have begun your search."
    2: "Though Rapture has fallen, plots are still in motion." (Your master=Big Sister, as she seems to be leading you to Rapture?)
    3: Your explanation seems to make sense. The old transportation system to Rapture still lies where it was, rusting away but maybe still of use.
    4: "If you should use it to reach Rapture, then seek it's Little Sisters, they wait beyond Raptures walls." Referencing how Rapture is a different world then the one you come from.
    5: "Follow the Reports of abductions and you will find this transportation to Rapture."
    6: "This is Oscar Myer, September 1958." This date causes some controversy on part of all the information we can think of...

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    182
    I don't think that "your master's temple has fallen" means Rapture in the first place. It may be a hint (double meaning, like the first message), but we should consider the context of the message more. The tape was in Lutwidge's burnt down workshop. The message on the tape referred to that and the tape itself quite clearly ("ashes of my quest" -> burnt workshop, "echoes of my voice" -> the tape). I think the message in the box does the same. "Your master's temple" would then also be the workshop and the master of course Lutwidge himself.
    "Turn south by west" also refers to the workshop as the starting point. Since it's in Lower Manhattan, as the newspaper clipping tells us, "great Muhheakantuck" is of course the Hudson River.

    I doubt all the complex theories developed in the discussion thread are close to the truth. Remember, the teaser site was made for the average viewer, not for ingenious riddle-solvers. I also don't think the second message directly points to Rapture. That would be too simple for Lutwidge. But the thought of something like an old ship or even an abandoned submarine lying at the mouth of Hudson River, holding the next riddle, is appealing.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Hidden
    Posts
    2,518
    Quote Originally Posted by Meltzer View Post
    But the thought of something like an old ship or even an abandoned submarine lying at the mouth of Hudson River, holding the next riddle, is appealing.
    I'd rather it actually lead to Rapture, then held a clue...

    I just want to see the room, all messed up by the Big Sister, with one note standing out. "I have gone to the Red Queen. You may have taken my daughter, but you won't stop me from finding her!"

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    182
    As I said, this would be too simple for Lutwidge. Why should he make all those puzzles and cryptic messages, just to put Mark in a submarine after the second one? No, there will be some more riddles. 2K needs to fill the time till October somehow

  8. #8
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    Hidden
    Posts
    2,518
    Maybe he tries to use it to get to Rapture, but it begins to take on water, and he uses a life raft he brought to get back to shore.

    I've love to see all his angry writings on this... "Stupid ****ing old piece of ****!"

  9. #9
    Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Bubbles~ View Post
    Those are some really good theories... I thought "The Looking Glass" could have been the ocean since you can see yourself reflected in it just like a mirror... How long did it take you to write all of that?
    I like that thought. The 'mirror' is the ocean. Go through it: or under water, and you reach rapture. That sounds about right. And it took me about an hour to write that which was not bad.

    Quote Originally Posted by MegaScience View Post
    ...
    2: "Though Rapture has fallen, plots are still in motion." (Your master=Big Sister, as she seems to be leading you to Rapture?)
    ...
    Big sister does not exist in 1958 when the message was left. 1958 was just before the first game and since we know that Big Sister is a Little Sister all grown up from the first game then the Red Queen cannot be her. Even though that is what I thought too at first.

    But I totally agree with everything else. Though I don't know how much Orrin knew at the time he left that message. He seems to refer to adam and plasmids as magic; though maybe that's a disguise.

    Quote Originally Posted by Meltzer View Post
    I don't think that "your master's temple has fallen" means Rapture in the first place. It may be a hint (double meaning, like the first message), but we should consider the context of the message more. The tape was in Lutwidge's burnt down workshop. The message on the tape referred to that and the tape itself quite clearly ("ashes of my quest" -> burnt workshop, "echoes of my voice" -> the tape). I think the message in the box does the same. "Your master's temple" would then also be the workshop and the master of course Lutwidge himself.
    "Turn south by west" also refers to the workshop as the starting point. Since it's in Lower Manhattan, as the newspaper clipping tells us, "great Muhheakantuck" is of course the Hudson River.

    I doubt all the complex theories developed in the discussion thread are close to the truth. Remember, the teaser site was made for the average viewer, not for ingenious riddle-solvers. I also don't think the second message directly points to Rapture. That would be too simple for Lutwidge. But the thought of something like an old ship or even an abandoned submarine lying at the mouth of Hudson River, holding the next riddle, is appealing.
    Too true. I totally agree with everything you just said. I should have considered the context of the message a little more. Some parts of it could be self reference on Orrins part; like calling himself the master. That would change that tone...for a surface dweller he knows alot about rapture, how much does this guy know? Are there any hints at where he gets his info? I know you've been doing a really good job at keeping an eye on the site. And the double meaning idea is more than likely but I can't think of any more information that would give us. I'll think on it.

    And yes I believe that it was made for the average Bioshock fan and therefore is a game. Which also means it is solvable because the game makers want us to feel success. There's a whole section a game development to generating that kind of fun.

    And yes, the workshop makes a really good starting point and an obvious one because of it's location. So I guess that means that Meltzer has already started this journey and is well on his way.

    Quote Originally Posted by Meltzer View Post
    No, there will be some more riddles. 2K needs to fill the time till October somehow
    Agreed. There is no way they are going to bail now and leave a lull between now and the games release. All that hard work on their part wasted; I don't think so. The tease will go on for a while I think... and I quite like that fact. I'm actually having a lot of fun. I hope there is more that can be gained from this; I'd love to be able to work something out before it appears on the site.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Location
    Australia
    Posts
    1
    Quote Originally Posted by SplicedProgrammer View Post
    Agreed. There is no way they are going to bail now and leave a lull between now and the games release. All that hard work on their part wasted; I don't think so. The tease will go on for a while I think... and I quite like that fact. I'm actually having a lot of fun. I hope there is more that can be gained from this; I'd love to be able to work something out before it appears on the site.
    And it'll be that much more awesome if that something we worked out appeared in the game or had some reference to it

  11. #11
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    USA- Kansas City area
    Posts
    57
    I had similar thoughts though some different. I think this puzzle box can have it's recording changed. So it maybe an old puzzle box used to recuit but I think it has a more sinister purpose.

    1. A magus is plural of magi. Magi are also known as the wise men, someone knowledgable. I think this is reference to someone being a genius. It's a poetic way of saying you are smart and need to come to us.
    http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/magus

    2. Not sure. Could mean Rapture fallen status? Could mean the struggle between the US and the USSR? Could mean Mark's marriage and his "sanity"?

    3. The name he gives I think refers to the Hudson river. Now the shoulder could either be either the joint in the Hudson river. Or it could be the location of where New York and Long Island. I'm leaning toward the state one. As far as the decript red queen, think of the shape of the chess piece. It does kind of look like a lighthouse. So I looked up lighthouse in New York and I think I found an disused lighthouse in New York on the Hudson. It's called Jeffery's Hook.
    http://www.lighthousefriends.com/light.asp?ID=393

    4. To run a race also could mean to go down a river. And seek her jewels in her crown could refer to stars. Possible constelation.

    Or the to run her race could mean this: The Red Queen Race which is theory of evoulution. It states: "For an evolutionary system, continuing development is needed just in order to maintain its fitness relative to the systems it is co-evolving with." But this wasn't discovered til 1973. Darn it.
    Last edited by srpinky; 07-12-2009 at 06:20 PM.

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Location
    In bed with Amanda Meltzer
    Posts
    65
    The light-house theory is very interesting !! You might be on to something there, especially when you consider that the opening scene of Bioshock had you swimming to a building in the middle of the ocean that looked suspicioulsy like a light-house

    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v485/B0XTER/BS.jpg

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by srpinky View Post
    Magi are also known as the wise men...It's a poetic way of saying you are smart and need to come to us.
    This has merit. Magus is giving someone a high title. You could easily be right about that.

    Quote Originally Posted by srpinky View Post
    2. Not sure. Could mean Rapture fallen status? Could mean the struggle between the US and the USSR? Could mean Mark's marriage and his "sanity"?
    Might mean the first two but certainly not the third. That message was recorded in 1958...10 years ago from Meltzer's time. There is no way that Lutwidge could have known that unless he has some sort of premonition ability that we don't know about. Highly unlikely the last option. But it certainly could mean the fall of rapture or as (the 2f forums user) Meltzer said it could have a double meaning.

    And I had not even considered the US vs USSR struggle but I do fail to see what it has to do with the path to Rapture. Especially because Lutwidge wanted to leave a timeless path behind (i'm assuming) to get to Rapture.

    Quote Originally Posted by srpinky View Post
    3. The name he gives I think refers to the Hudson river. Now the shoulder could either be either the joint in the Hudson river. Or it could be the location of where New York and Long Island. I'm leaning toward the state one. As far as the decript red queen, think of the shape of the chess piece. It does kind of look like a lighthouse. So I looked up lighthouse in New York and I think I found an disused lighthouse in New York on the Hudson. It's called Jeffery's Hook.
    http://www.lighthousefriends.com/light.asp?ID=393
    Of course!!! That makes so much sense it's incredible and the lighthouse you picked matches the bill perfectly and "is one of the few left". No only that but it does indeed lie on a shoulder of the river. Nice find!

    Quote Originally Posted by srpinky View Post
    4. To run a race also could mean to go down a river. And seek her jewels in her crown could refer to stars. Possible constelation.
    It is indeed possible in a use the stars to guide you sort of way. Worth looking into. I might look at the star charts around that area... ( I'll get back about that soon enough)

    Quote Originally Posted by srpinky View Post
    Or the to run her race could mean this: The Red Queen Race which is theory of evoulution. It states: "For an evolutionary system, continuing development is needed just in order to maintain its fitness relative to the systems it is co-evolving with." But this wasn't discovered til 1973. Darn it.
    And the red queens race in this context is almost certainly either the race of the river (making the red queen the submersible) or it refers to something that gets you nowhere. It is not the biology version of the matter (and the science version has more merit but is unlikely too). [See Wikipedia for "red queens race"]

    Quote Originally Posted by ICF View Post
    The light-house theory is very interesting !! You might be on to something there, especially when you consider that the opening scene of Bioshock had you swimming to a building in the middle of the ocean that looked suspicioulsy like a light-house

    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v485/B0XTER/BS.jpg
    You might be onto something there. Maybe we should consider the images we see in the context of lighthouse items and terms. Getting to Rapture may very well be marked by the worlds lighthouses...I think that's an idea worth persuing. Has anybody seen lighthouse like images in Rapture symbolism?

  14. #14
    I will give credit for this to Kyburz because I'm pretty sure he is the one that posted this in the main viral site thread. He mentioned:

    That the 'Red Queen' could be referring to the statue of liberty. I know it is green now because the metal has oxidized, but brand new the statue would have been a coppery color, goldish/reddish ---> "Red Queen". The "decrepit corpse" could be meaning that it has aged and oxidized over time. The "looking glass" could be the observation area in it's "crown jewels" (crown atop the head), and one could be looking at a certain series of stars (celestial navigation) to find their way to Rapture. As splicedprogrammer stated, and was mentioned by Kyburz this weekend, a magus was known for their ability to navigate using stars.

    I honestly thought that made the most sense of anything I've heard.
    Last edited by Fox K 56; 07-13-2009 at 04:54 AM.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Location
    Minnesota
    Posts
    243
    I don't think the box is a lock for directions, but instead a test for knowledge. As the average citizen probably won't be able to open it (I couldn’t) it'll be left for the person who really wants to find Rapture.

    1. This is just an introduction to the person who wants to find rapture
    2. I think the master is Lutwidge and the temple is his house. So his house maybe burnt down but he won't stop working, or there will be more clues. It seems that he knew that the walls around his house won't last forever.
    3. I'm a little confused by this one, and the turn south by west. I think turn south by west is not directions but it means "effort". Example: Turn south by west to find eternal peace. You can't turn south or go west to find eternal peace but instead you can put in effort to try and reach it. You said that "Muhheakantuck refers to a river that flows both ways". So I’m just going to stretch the word and say something that "flows" both ways. So if you put in enough effort to find Rapture and go one way, there will be people who are going to try and stop you and push you back the other way. The second part of three I think is referring to Rapture as being the red queen. Red will be Andrew Ryan who is the king and his queen is rapture "Red's queen". I think is red because red=communism which communism=Russia and I think Ryan is from Russia. So the red queen is a decrepit corpse or going to be one.
    4. The race will be the fight to get to rapture, like I said what Muhheakantuck means in three. Her crown jewels just refer to the stuff inside rapture waiting beyond the oceans surface.
    5. I think it means to follow the clues of rapture, so you can get there. Twinkling=clues, gems=Rapture.
    6. I think this is his name, but don't correct me I could be wrong

    If you’re lazy to read what I put up above it says that the box is just saying that there will be more clues to get to Rapture. P.S. I got a little lazy typing three and everything after it

    Off topic
    Quote Originally Posted by Meltzer View Post
    As I said, this would be too simple for Lutwidge. Why should he make all those puzzles and cryptic messages, just to put Mark in a submarine after the second one? No, there will be some more riddles. 2K needs to fill the time till October somehow
    I do agree that there will be more riddles but even if Mark leaves to find rapture more stuff could be happening to the apartment. Like Amanda coming in the apartment and leaving a note, or some mysterious person comes in and ransacks the place

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •