Tonic Collector Trophy Glitch?

[Liquidus]

Okay I've been trying to get this trophy for 2 days now and all I can come up with is that it's a glitch.

On my first playthrough I managed to get 53 Tonics in the Physical, Combat, and Engineering fields. I looked at the trophy requirement and saw that you needed 58, meh I said "screw it, I'll just get it next time".

On my second playthrough I got 53 again. This time I searched EVERY single nook and cranny of BioShock...still 53.

Third playthrough, well only 53. I crossed referenced all the trophies I have with the 360 version and I have all the same ones as they do (including the DLC ones) so I don't know anymore unless these 5 missing tonics are associated with the upcoming (hopefully free) DLC.

EDIT:

By the way these are all the Tonics I've found:

Physical Tonics:

1. Hackers Delight
2. Eve Link
3. Extra Nutrition
4. Scrounger
5. Extra Nutrition 2
6. Sport Boost
7. Medical Expert
8. Eve Saver
9. Sport Boost 2
10. Security Envasion
11. Extra Nutrition 3
12. Medical Expert 2
13. Security Envasion 2
14. Booze Hound
15. Bloodlust
16. Medical Expert 3
17. Hackers Delight 2
18. Hackers Delight 3
19. Eve Link 2

Engineering Tonics:

1. Security Expert
2. Shorten Alarms
3. Focused Hacker
4. Vending Expert
5. Security Expert 2
6. Hacking Expert
7. Vending Expert 2
8. Alarm Expert
9. Short Alarms 2
10. Speedy Hacker 2
11. Clever Inventor
12. Focused Hacker 2
13. Alarm Expert 2
14. Hacking Expert 2
15. Safecracker 2
16. Prolific Inventor

Combat Tonics:

1. Wrench Jockey
2. Static Discharge
3. Static Discharge 2
4. Photographers Eye 2
5. Wrench Lurker
6. Machine Buster
7. Human Inferno
8. Photographers Eye
9. Frozen Field
10. Wrench Jockey 2
11. Electric Flesh
12. Frozen Field 2
13. Wrench Lurker 2
14. Machine Buster 2
15. Electric Flesh 2
16. Damage Research 2
17. Human Inferno 2
18. Armored Shell

[Wild_Guns]

Please one topic: http://forums.2kgames.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23548
However i can assure you the trophy works correctly, i have it.

[Liquidus]

Sorry about that.

You can lock this if you want.