hmm ok Ill eliminate him then..
So my new official total list
maddjin (esp mongols but all civs)
salmeen (esp arabs but all civs)
and a gap...
SPVM (all)
rawjos (?)
Civaddict (spain/china)
Liam Sutty (teching civs only)
sniperkill (rome)
civ addict seemed to use some quite smart battle tactics at times even if his macro strategy wasnt as strong as the xbox types. mad and salmeen just played more or less xbox top level play. Liam just surprises you with tech and sniper had top level defense with romans - it can be like attacking that pesky elthrasher on the xbox.
Im inclined to see civ strategy as having advanced over time so for example thrasher now is stronger than the guys who used to dominate ages ago. So the emphasis is on people in the reasonably recent era - except the very recent because of how ps3 comunity has died down.
I have played Spainful, Friendlypostman and i think el commandatee and again with due respect they dont stick out in my mind... Im sure they are good but Im looking for some sort of "OMG how did they do that..."
